I'm pretty sure you didn't get it from me because I knew it was just supposition (not to mention not very interesting) and never bothered to discuss it before and as I don't write fanfiction I don't have to worry about what other people think. I am wondering if it was in that dreadful fic you betaed and asked me to check. I think it works either way depending on what you think the point of "last year" was. I wouldn't pick anyone up on saying either 2nd or 3rd year although I might if anyone said someone was wrong for thinking the opposite.